Wednesday, October 7, 2026
They Buried
We Dug It Up
⌕ Search

Letters to the Editor

Readers write to the desk. We print the ones that argue with us as readily as the ones that agree — and we mark the ones that made us change something.

Letters are edited only for length and clarity, never for sense, and the writer sees the edit before it prints. Write to letters@theyburied.com. 21 letters are printed on this page; 5 of them changed a story.

Letters that changed something

Halvard Sørensen-RuizCopenhagen

This letter changed the story

Since your comment section is apparently not moderated into silence, I will use it. My reply above is accurate and I stand by it. I would add only that Dr. Nkemelu's transliteration of line 8 is better than mine and I have adopted it in my own notes. Scholarship is not a war.

On A Clay Tablet Logs 18 Tonnes Of Missing Gold And One Excuse.

Perpetua NkemeluThe antiquities desk

Thank you. I have adopted your reading of the determinative in line 4, which I got wrong and which you were too polite to say in print.

Hester AboyadeBaltimore

This letter changed the story

The dissent is better than the majority opinion and the board knows it. Print the vote count on the ownership page too, not just here.

On Twenty-Two Per Cent Of Our Income Comes From Someone We Cannot Name.

Bett NakagawaOpinion desk

Fair. The vote counts for 1996, 2011 and 2026 are being added to /ownership this week.

Solveig Barrantes-NgTrondheim

This letter changed the story

For anyone wanting to reproduce it: any version below 3.11, any input under about -70 dBFS, decimate by 8. You will get your twelve bits. I got mine from a file of zeros.

On The Signal From Orbit Was Coming From Our Laptop

Ambrose TeagueOff-World desk

Pinned by request of the standards editor: I published a measurement taken on one instrument. That was against every instinct I have from nineteen years in air traffic control, where you never trust a single return, and I did it anyway because I was excited. Do not be excited.

Marguerite OllivanderBoston

This letter changed the story

I was the examiner who could not reach a conclusion. Thank you for printing that as a finding rather than burying it. Most commissioning clients ask me to try harder.

On They Agreed Never To Use The Word 'Central'

Wilhelmina Oduya-FletcherBinghamton, New York

This letter changed the story

He moved it four inches and put my name on it. I did not expect either. The coefficient is 0.03 and I will send him the 2027 figure in January.

On I Have Been Wrong 3,388 Times. Here Is The Breakdown.

The postbag

D. FerreiraLisbon

Eleven months. Eleven months. You people report the gap in the provenance every single time and I have never once seen another outlet do it. I disagree with roughly half of what this desk prints and I renewed my subscription this morning.

On A Clay Tablet Logs 18 Tonnes Of Missing Gold And One Excuse.

Wendell R. FrostThe editor's office

For the record, and because Ms Ashcombe-Doyle quoted me exactly: yes. All three. The Null Result on this subject is commissioned as of Monday and Dr. Nkemelu is writing it, which she volunteered for before I asked.

On The Stories You Love Most Are The Ones We Do Worst

Dolores Wisniewski-TrantAurora, Colorado

My father would have hated being in a newspaper and he would have read this four times. He kept everything because he thought somebody would need it one day. I did not believe him.

On There Is A Railway Station Under Denver Airport

Anonymous by request of the deskOhio

I have believed this for four years. I read the whole thing twice. The part that got me was not the borders or the registers, it was Ojala saying he writes back to everyone. I am going to write to him.

On We Went Looking For Finland. We Found It.

Aino Kelloniemi-RaskTornio

Your reporters walked 1,340 km of border in February. In FEBRUARY. I offered them the car four times. Please tell them the coffee is still on the Swedish side and it is still cheaper.

On We Went Looking For Finland. We Found It.

Corina Baptiste-NgSan Jose

I asked them to print the firm's name. They refused and told me why in the piece. I still disagree. I am glad the disagreement is on the page instead of in an email.

On Half The Traffic Was Not People

Priyanka Ramaswamy-OhlssonBengaluru

The offer stands and it is not rhetorical. I have a vacuum chamber, I have time in it, and I will run anyone's device and publish the result whichever way it goes. Nine people have taken me up on it in eleven years. Nine devices. Zero thrust below 10⁻³ mbar.

On The Examiner Mentioned The Secrecy Act. The Applicant Vanished.

R. Nwankwo-TraskAthens, Georgia

Pathologist here. For the readers asking: yes, the grackle tumour was benign, no, it did not contain anything, and yes, I photographed it from four angles because I knew someone would ask.

On We Dissected Four Hundred Birds. They Were Birds.

Yusuf Aldridge-KoneBirmingham

I am not a scientist and I want people to know how boring the method was. I downloaded the raw series, wrote 40 lines of code, and got a different answer than the paper. Then I did it again to check I had not made a mistake. That is the whole skill.

On Three Centuries Went Missing. Then The Authors Found The Typo.

Collected letters pages